About GenslerOnLifestyle

We enjoy our lives in many ways. GenslerOnLifestyle offers ideas and insights about how design can make leisure more accessible and enjoyable.

Search GenslerOn
Lifestyle Topics
Connect with Us
« Defining the Brand, Part 1 | Main | Gensler’s Consumer Insights Series: The Future is Now »

What Color is the Dress: Or (The Importance of Lighting in Retail Environments)

The difference between poor lighting (left) and good lighting (right) in a retail environment cannot be overstated. Image © Tumblr and Ryan Gobuty

The Internet is literally blowing up with a question posed on Tumblr over the color of a dress. A photo posted to the site shows a striped dress taken with a cellphone that can, depending on your eye sensitivity or screen brightness, appear either white and gold or black and blue. Besides driving untold numbers of people nuts trying to figure out what color the dress really is, it now has developed its own hashtag battle: #whiteandgold versus #blackandblue. You know things are serious when they elicit a hashtag battle.

The truth of the matter is that the dress really is black and blue, but a combination of a poor cellphone photo and some questionable lighting decisions in the space the photo was taken have caused a tsunami of Internet commentary and consternation. I believe this is an example of a larger issue in our ever growing world of social connectivity via mobile devices. Last year over 27,800 photos were uploaded to Instagram every minute. Facebook clocked in at 208,300 per minute. That is impressive, but if we assume, as I do, that most of these photos were taken with or generated on a mobile device connected to the Internet, then what we are seeing is very dependent on the quality of the camera device and the user. This is problematic for some if they happen to rely, represent or sell the item, place or activity being photographed. It is in their best interest to show the subject matter in the best light, if you will.

Which brings me to the subject of this rant: lighting and space design really matter. And they matter even more now that spaces are being represented to millions of people who experience them through a digital portal rather than in person. The dress in the photo appeared white and gold to a significant number of viewers: at one point a survey clocked in 70% or more seeing this color combo, due to an optical illusion exacerbated by the overexposed cellphone snap. A blue and black dress will appear more white and gold if under a bluer tone of lighting (who’d have thought?).

Sellers of product, with their professional photo-shoots and expensive marketing campaigns, will lose more and more control of their visual message to social networks and mobile campaigns driven by consumers that may not take the care to show a dress in the best light. It is in everyone’s best interest to show the dress in the best light and call attention to its best assets.

Ryan Fetters is an Associate and designer in the San Francisco office. He has been with Gensler for 5+ years and has been involved in a range of projects from a historic building addition at the UC Berkeley campus to multiple retail and hospitality ventures. Ryan is fascinated with how people engage with a space and technology to enhance and improve their experience therein. Strategizing and conceptualizing how customers will interact with a new design makes his day and he strives to keep up with the most recent trends and opportunities within the design world. Contact him at ryan_fetters@gensler.com.

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

Reader Comments (7)

But with this dress it's still the lipstick equation. Doesn't matter how good your lighting is if your dress is ugly. And that' one ugly dress.
02.27.2015 | Unregistered Commenteraj
What a great, timely post ! Lighting is such an important part of any space and often an afterthought. Worst yet is when the bulb burns out and gets replaced with a different temperature lamp-- then you have a variety of colors in a space. Thanks for posting.
03.3.2015 | Unregistered CommenterDave Broz
I've been in lighting for a while now, and this is a most bizzare phenomenom. I've just asked my co-workers to look at this post on my monitor screen and four of them saw a blue and black and three a white and golden dress.
I agree that lighting is THE most important aspect for creating any sort of environment or showcasing a product. And this example makes it achingly clear how intricate and subjective a topic this is. No software can adequately predict what people will actually see.
And I don't agree with the first post. Using the right techniques you can make any product look appealing.
03.11.2015 | Unregistered CommenterAlex Karzalow
A major part. The bulb burns down outside and is change with a the various temperature when it is the most evil.
03.13.2015 | Unregistered Commenteramazon hawkeye
Excellent Ryan. I have saying lighting from the start. And not to mention Digital cameras take white balance from the brightest spot in the frame. In this case that's outside and the dress is in the shade which is a different color balance. So it would not be reproduced correctly.
03.20.2015 | Unregistered CommenterJohn Abernathy
There has been a lot of speculations about the color of this dress, and according to me the dress was black and blue rather than white and golden. You can also get more details on dresses at http://www.casual-plus.com/html/dresses.html online.
04.4.2015 | Unregistered CommenterAnna Wise
Andhra Pradesh Board of Secondary Education is going to be release AP Intermediate 2nd / second year Results (IPE Results) on 28th April, through BIE official website bie.cgg.gov.in, it is the official intermediate Results (IPE Results) site, AP Intermediate 2nd / second year results (IPE Results) date was announced by educational minister of Andhra Pradesh State Mr. G. Srinivas Rao and official Intermediate Board members, at the time of AP Intermediate first year Results (IPE Results) announcement. Again AP Intermediate 2nd / second Year Results (IPE Results) will be released by the same education Minister on April 28th.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.